Lauren LaVera Sienna David Howard Thornton Art the Clown Elliott Fullam Jonathan Samantha Scaffidi Victoria Heyes Casey Hartnett Allie Felissa Rose Ms. Principe Sarah Grace Sanders Trick or Treat Little Girl's Mom Griffin Santopietro Eric Tamara Glynn Shopping Mother Devon Roth Stephanie Charlie McElveen Jeff Chris Irvine Burke Jenna Kanell Tara Heyes Catherine Corcoran Dawn Katie Maguire Monica Brown Scout Taylor-Compton