Hugh Jackman P. T. Barnum Zac Efron Phillip Carlyle Michelle Williams Charity Barnum Rebecca Ferguson Jenny Lind Zendaya Anne Wheeler Keala Settle Lettie Lutz Yahya Abdul-Mateen II W. D. Wheeler Natasha Liu Bordizzo Deng Yan Paul Sparks James Gordon Bennett Sam Humphrey Charles Stratton Austyn Johnson Caroline Barnum Cameron Seely Helen Barnum Eric Anderson Mr. O'Malley Ellis Rubin Young P. T. Barnum Skylar Dunn Young Charity Hallett Daniel Everidge Lord of Leeds Radu Spinghel O'Clancy Yusaku Komori Chang Bunker Danial Son Eng Bunker Will Swenson Philo Barnum Byron Jennings Mr. Carlyle Betsy Aidem Mrs. Carlyle Damian Young Mr. Winthrop Tina Benko Mrs. Winthrop Fredric Lehne Benjamin Hallett Kathryn Meisle Hannah Hallett Gayle Rankin Queen Victoria Michael Barra Stage Manager Ben Reed Mill Worker Taylor James Dancer Oddity #4 Madison Smith Pointe Ballerina #7 James Babson Additional Voices (voice)