Drew Barrymore Paula / Candy Michael Zegen Steve T. J. Miller Louis Holland Taylor Barbara Cox Michelle Buteau Ingrid Teddy Coluca Ron Andrew Rannells Nico Wendy Meredith Kyra Ellie Kemper Jenna Jones Charlie Barnett Simon Adrian Martinez Reporter Banjo Richard Kind Wes Murray Bartlett Terry Dolly Wells Second AD Daisy John W. Lawson Lance Lena Dunham Lisa Jennifer Lim Vicky Adrian Matilla Officer York Savannah Guthrie Savannah Guthrie Meghan McCain Meghan McCain Jimmy Fallon Jimmy Fallon Andy Cohen Andy Cohen Bridget Everett Bridget Everett Graham Norton Graham Norton Jason Kennedy Jason Kennedy Kelly Ripa Kelly Ripa Ryan Seacrest Ryan Seacrest