Judy Greer Grace Bradley Pete Holmes Bob Bradley Molly Belle Wright Beth Bradley Lauren Graham Narrator / Adult Beth Bradley (voice) Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez Charlie Bradley Matthew Lamb Claude Herdman Beatrice Schneider Imogene Herdman Lorelei Olivia Mote Alice Wendleken Danielle Hoetmer Mrs. Wendleken Kirk B.R. Woller Reverend Hopkins Elizabeth Tabish Mrs. Grady Vanessa Benavente First Grade Teacher Lauren Cochrane Nurse Pond Daina Leitold Mrs. Hopkins Jenni Burke Ms. Graebner Stephanie Sy Mrs. Thomas Tom Young George Armstrong Adam Hurtig Mr. Grady Stanlee Arches Ticket Taker Sarah Constible Mrs. Slocum Zoe Fish Choir Kid #1 Reena Jolly Ms. Warren