Gabriel LaBelle Lorne Michaels Rachel Sennott Rosie Shuster Cory Michael Smith Chevy Chase Ella Hunt Gilda Radner Dylan O'Brien Dan Aykroyd Emily Fairn Laraine Newman Matt Wood John Belushi Lamorne Morris Garrett Morris Kim Matula Jane Curtin Tommy Dewey Michael O'Donoghue Cooper Hoffman Dick Ebersol Nicholas Braun Andy Kaufman / Jim Henson Andrew Barth Feldman Neil Levy Finn Wolfhard NBC Page Willem Dafoe David Tebet Stephen Badalamenti Lobby Security Guard Ellen Boscov Mrs. Kaufman John Dinello Shop Steward J.K. Simmons Milton Berle Presley Coley Barbara Gallagher Kaia Gerber Jacqueline Carlin Catherine Curtin Joan Carbunkle Nicholas Podany Billy Crystal Corinne Britti Valri Bromfield Justin Matthew Smith Joe Dicso Matthew Rhys George Carlin Taylor Gray Al Franken Jon Batiste Billy Preston Josh Brener Alan Zweibel Tracy Letts Herb Sargent Brad Garrett Borscht Belt Comedian Billy Bryk Carl Robert Wuhl Dave Wilson Drew Scheid Bob Pook Jeff Pope Scotty Schachter Jeff Witzke Johnny Carson (voice)